Should I Resurface or Replace Asphalt? A Comprehensive Guide by Southern Asphalt Engineering

asphalt resurfacing guide

How long has it been since your last professional assessment of your asphalt surfaces? Over time, without regular upkeep, signs of wear, like cracks and potholes, can emerge in your own asphalt driveways or parking lots. The crucial question arises: Should you completely replace or resurface your asphalt?

Understanding the key differences between asphalt resurfacing and replacement is not just about immediate repairs; it’s about strategic long-term care that can significantly extend the lifespan of old asphalt and your paved surfaces. With the right approach to maintenance and repair, your asphalt infrastructure and paved surface can remain robust and functional for up to two decades or more.

This comprehensive guide will delve into the major issues and nuances of asphalt pavement resurfacing and replacement. We aim to equip you with the knowledge to make the best decision for the longevity and quality of your existing asphalt and surfaces.

Understanding Asphalt Damage

Asphalt surfaces in South Florida endure a lot – from extreme weather conditions to constant wear and tear. Common types of serious asphalt surface damage include:

  • Cracks: Small, hairline fractures that can widen over time.
  • Potholes: Caused by water seeping into the pavement, freezing, and expanding.
  • Fading: Due to UV exposure, leading to a loss of asphalt binder and aggregate.

Each type of structural damage has a different impact and calls for a specific approach to repair and proper maintenance afterward.

What is Asphalt Resurfacing?

Asphalt resurfacing involves the curing process of adding a new layer of asphalt over the already existing surface of the pavement. This process includes:

  1. Cleaning: Removing debris and fixing minor damages.
  2. Laying New Asphalt: Applying a fresh layer, typically 1.5 to 2 inches thick.

Benefits of Resurfacing asphalt pavement

  • Cost-Effective: Less expensive than a full replacement.
  • Time-Efficient: Can be completed quickly, minimizing disruption.
  • Extends Pavement Life: Adds years to your asphalt’s lifespan.

Ideal Situations for Resurfacing with Asphalt Paving 

Resurfacing is particularly suitable for pavements that show signs of surface deterioration but still have a structurally sound foundation. This includes minor cracks or wearing away of the surface layer of damaged asphalt, where the damage hasn’t yet penetrated the deeper layers of asphalt. In scenarios where the new surface of the pavement is aging but not severely damaged, resurfacing offers a practical and cost-effective solution. It revitalizes the appearance of the asphalt, extends its lifespan, and improves safety, all without the need for a complete overhaul.

  • Minor Damages: Surface-level issues with a solid foundation.
  • Aged Asphalt: When the surface is worn but the base layer is intact.

What is Asphalt Replacement?

Asphalt replacement, unlike resurfacing, involves removing and completely replacing the entire thickness of the asphalt pavement.

Benefits of Replacement

  • Long-Term Solution: Addresses deep structural issues.
  • Durability: New asphalt offers greater longevity and resilience.

Scenarios for Replacing Asphalt Driveway or Parking Lot

Replacement becomes necessary when the pavement has suffered more extensive damage beyond surface-level issues. This is typically in cases where the base layer of the pavement is compromised due to water damage, severe cracking, or when the pavement has repeatedly been resurfaced. Such conditions often result in large potholes and areas where the top layer of asphalt is crumbling, indicating a failure that resurfacing cannot adequately address. In these instances, a full replacement with new pavement is not just recommended; it’s essential for safety, longevity, and structural integrity.

  • Severe Damage: When the base layer is compromised.
  • Old, Fatigued Asphalt: In cases where multiple resurfacing has already been done.

Comparing Asphalt Resurfacing vs. Replacement

asphalt resurfacing table

When to Choose Resurfacing

Choose resurfacing when the current pavement shows superficial damage but the underlying foundation is still strong and intact. It’s ideal for managing budgets effectively while ensuring the new driveway and pavement remain safe and functional. Resurfacing is a smart decision for extending the life of your driveway and pavement without the higher costs and longer downtime associated with full pavement replacement.

Opt for resurfacing when:

  • The damage is superficial.
  • The base layer is stable and undamaged.
  • Budget constraints are a consideration.

When to Opt for Replacement

Opting for replacement is advised when the pavement’s foundation is no longer reliable. This might be due to severe damage like large, very deep cracks, potholes or significant structural problems that compromise the pavement sub base’s integrity. While it is more costly and time-consuming, replacement ensures that the pavement is entirely rejuvenated, with a new, strong foundation that can withstand years of use. It’s a long-term investment in your property, ensuring safety and durability.

Replacement is necessary when:

  • The foundation has structural issues.
  • There are large, deep potholes.
  • The pavement has deteriorated extensively.

Consulting with Asphalt Contractor Professionals

At Southern Asphalt Engineering, we stress the importance of professional consultation with pavement professionals. Our team can assess your pavement’s condition and recommend the most suitable option, backed by years of experience and expertise.

Understanding the nuances between asphalt resurfacing and replacement is crucial for maintaining your property’s value and functionality. Southern Asphalt Engineering is committed to providing top-notch asphalt repair and complete replacement solutions tailored to your needs.

For personalized advice on repair needs or to schedule an assessment, contact Southern Asphalt Engineering, your trusted partner in asphalt maintenance and repair in Miami.

    Request and Estimate